Skip to main content

Web Design4 min read

How to Evaluate a Web Design Agency's Portfolio

A portfolio is the most important tool for evaluating a web design agency — but most people look at the wrong things. Here's how to assess portfolios like a professional.

James Foss

Founder, Linear Web Solutions

November 16, 2026
Share

Browsing portfolio screenshots on a web design agency's website is the least useful way to evaluate their work. Screenshots can't tell you if the sites load fast, rank on Google, work well on mobile, or convert visitors into customers. Here's how to evaluate a portfolio in a way that actually predicts whether an agency will produce a site that works for your business.

Step 1: Find the Actual Live Sites

Most portfolios include enough information to find the actual published website. Search the business name shown in the portfolio screenshot, or ask the agency for URLs to their live portfolio sites. Real sites tell you far more than screenshots.

Step 2: Test Mobile Performance

Open each portfolio site on your actual phone. Notice:

  • How quickly does it load on mobile?
  • Is the navigation intuitive to use with a finger?
  • Is text readable without zooming?
  • Are buttons and call-to-action elements prominent?
  • Does the phone number appear at the top in a tappable format?

Any agency building websites for local businesses should produce sites that feel excellent on mobile. Sites that are awkward or slow on mobile — regardless of how they look on a desktop monitor — are not the work of an agency that prioritizes business outcomes.

Step 3: Run PageSpeed Insights

Go to pagespeed.web.dev and run each portfolio site through Google's PageSpeed Insights tool. Look at the mobile score (more important than desktop for Google rankings). Scores above 80 are good; above 90 are excellent. Scores below 60 indicate websites that are actively hurting their owners' Google rankings.

This single test reveals more about an agency's technical quality than any amount of sales conversation. An agency whose portfolio of sites consistently scores well on mobile PageSpeed has the technical discipline to build for performance.

Step 4: Search for the Site in Google

Search for the business's target keywords on Google. Do their portfolio clients rank? A plumbing company in an agency's portfolio — do they appear in local search results? If the agency builds websites that consistently don't rank, the sites look nice but aren't delivering business value.

Step 5: Evaluate the Business Logic

Look at each portfolio site as a business tool, not an art object:

  • Is there a visible, prominent phone number above the fold?
  • Is there a clear call to action on the homepage?
  • Are customer reviews or testimonials visible?
  • Is the content specific to the business's location and services?

These conversion fundamentals separate sites built to generate leads from sites built to win design awards.


See Our Portfolio and Results

Contact Linear Web Solutions and ask us to walk you through our portfolio — including PageSpeed scores, Google rankings, and client outcomes for the sites we've built.

Related Pages

web design portfoliohiring web designerweb design agencyweb design evaluation

Frequently asked questions

What if an agency's portfolio is all screenshots with no live sites?

Ask for URLs to live sites. If they can't or won't provide them, that's a significant concern. Every legitimate agency can share live examples of their work.

Should I care about the industries in the portfolio?

Somewhat. An agency with extensive local service business experience will bring relevant knowledge to your project. That said, a skilled agency can build effectively across industries.

Can I ask for client references beyond what's in the portfolio?

Always. Ask specifically about the post-launch experience: Was the agency responsive when issues arose? Did the site perform as expected? Would they hire them again?

Is a newer agency with a smaller portfolio worse than an established one?

Not necessarily. A newer agency whose smaller portfolio shows consistent performance quality may outperform an established agency whose large portfolio includes significant weak work. Quality within the portfolio matters more than quantity.

Share

More in Web Design