Skip to main content

Web Design3 min read

Questions to Ask an SEO Agency Before Signing a Contract

SEO contracts are often long and commitments are significant. These are the specific questions you need answered before signing with any SEO agency.

James Foss

Founder, Linear Web Solutions

November 15, 2026
Share

SEO contracts are often 6–12 months long with monthly fees ranging from several hundred to several thousand dollars. Choosing the wrong agency is an expensive mistake — not just in direct fees, but in the opportunity cost of months where your rankings don't improve while a competitor pulls ahead. These questions will separate legitimate SEO professionals from agencies selling vague promises.

Questions About Process and Deliverables

"What specific activities do you perform each month for my fee?"

A legitimate SEO agency can give you a concrete list: X hours of on-page optimization, X new pages or blog posts, citation building on Y directories, monthly GBP management and posting, link building outreach, monthly ranking report with specific keyword tracking. Vague answers like "comprehensive SEO services" are a red flag.

"Who will actually be working on my account?"

Many large agencies sell large account teams in pitches and then hand you to a junior coordinator or overseas team. Know exactly who will be doing the work and their experience level.

"What CMS and hosting do you recommend and why?"

An agency that recommends proprietary platforms where you can only be hosted through them is creating dependency. Legitimate agencies work with your existing setup or recommend platforms you fully own.

Questions About Reporting and Results

"What does a monthly report look like?"

Request a sample report. It should include keyword ranking trends, organic traffic changes (from Google Search Console or Analytics), and attribution of specific activities to outcomes. A report that just shows "we made 15 changes to your website" with no ranking or traffic data is not useful.

"What's a realistic timeline for results in my market?"

Legitimate answers: 3–6 months for initial ranking movement in less competitive markets; 6–12 months in competitive categories. Any answer of "30 days" or "guaranteed results" is dishonest.

Questions About Red Flags

"Can you guarantee first-page rankings?"

No legitimate agency can guarantee specific rankings. Google's algorithm is not in anyone's control. If they say yes, leave.

"What will you be doing to build links to my site?"

Link building tactics range from legitimate (outreach, content creation, local citations) to harmful (link farms, paid links). Agencies that use harmful tactics can get your site penalized. Ask specifically what their link-building approach is.


Get SEO from an Agency That Shows Its Work

Contact Linear Web Solutions for a transparent conversation about our local SEO process, what we deliver each month, and what results look like in your specific market.

Related Pages

SEO agency questionshiring SEOSEO vettinglocal SEO agency

Frequently asked questions

What's a fair length for an SEO contract?

6 months minimum is reasonable (SEO takes time). Beyond 12 months without performance milestone review is unusual. Ensure you can exit if results don't materialize within a defined period.

Should I sign a long-term contract with an SEO agency?

A 6-month initial engagement with month-to-month thereafter (after demonstrating results) is a fair structure. Be wary of agencies demanding 12–24 month contracts without performance checkpoints.

How do I verify an agency's claimed results?

Ask for references from clients in similar markets and industries. Request access to verify their claimed ranking improvements in Google Search Console data (real data, not screenshots of rankings that can be faked with location spoofing).

What's the difference between black-hat and white-hat SEO?

White-hat SEO uses legitimate, Google-approved techniques that build long-term rankings. Black-hat SEO uses manipulative techniques that may produce short-term results but risk penalties. Legitimate agencies only use white-hat techniques.

Share

More in Web Design